THE RUMOR: He's not just a legend on the field. According to a 2011 New York Post story, the retired New York Yankee shortstop treats his one-night stands to something special. No, not his phone number or a promise for a second date. How about a gift basket? Yes, sleeping with Jeter purportedly comes with a ride home and a basket of goodies that includes a Jeter-signed baseball. IS IT TRUE?: "It's a dumb story," Jeter responded in an interview. "And you really have to be dumber to believe it."